1.Why is Camille Paglia hating Lady Gaga so much?

2. How can Lady Gaga be not a good piano player while she went to NY University Tisch School of Art?

3. what is the writer's scale when criticizing her?

       As a singer and not a fan of Lady Gaga, I was shocked by reading the article. I thought the writer is an enemy of Lady Gaga. Pagila says that she did not perform well on BBC1's live performance of “My Poker Face". How could this be possible while she was one of the twenty people accepted in NY University Tisch School of Art. 

     Producers and music companies do advertising to sell their products by making super stars. But I think people who listen to the music have also a taste that makes one singer a more successful one. Not only listener’s taste matters, but also there is an epidemic fever among the youth to imitate their friends.

     Besides all these, I appreciate Lady Gaga in one thing, her courage to do what she wants to do. She has a mind that is not abandoned by the rules and frameworks. She does what she wants to. She is a brave woman in my opinion, someone who has followed her dreams, no matter what others think about it.

Pagila says her songs are depthless. Lady Gaga is a pop singer and population is the one who should like her or not. Her song lyrics might not seem very deep and literate, but that is wh at comes out of her mind new and creative. I like the beat and rhythm of her songs.

          Pagila thinks she is following Madona. But I think she is very creative and new. I also believe that some people resist against new creations and inventions, even in the field of art and music. In my point of view Pagila is one of those who cannot look outside the box and free her mind. At the end, even if we do not like or favor something new, we have the right not to like it, but I do not appreciate criticizing it in such a way that Pagila did to Lady Gaga. All of us have the right to do what we like to do. Here is the link to my first song and the lyrics.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y6SUDTN-wVw

not a follower not a leader

not good news

not a hi not a farewell,

not black not white

not as you say, neither as you think

and not as what has been written

not from sky not from earth

not a slave , and not imprisoned

not a slave of any religion

not a mirage, not a glass of wine for a lonely heart

not hell and not heaven

this is my nature

i'm the center of universe

hidden or visible

you don't know you are the center of love

you are full of secrets

you are the whole world